Blogroll
- Paris Olympics Opening Ceremony Predictably Seeks To Out-Satan Previous Satanist Productions, And May Have Succeeded
- Netanyahu Claimed In Speech Iran Threatened To Kill Trump; Alex Jones Believes It's Predictive Programming: "If Trump Gets Killed Now Because Of Netanyahu Saying That, HE Becomes A Prime Suspect."
- Offsite Post: ‘The US and the Black Abyss of Revolution’
- Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Issues Stark Warning To Americans That HHS Has Issued PREP Act Declaration For Bird Flu, Ordered 4.8 Million Doses Of Dangerous "Vaccine—" Kennedy Vows To Stop This Madness
- Why Is There No Joy after Communion?
- Interview 1894 – AI Ring of Steel Descends on Paris (NWNW 563)
- Netanyahu Gets 58 Standing Ovations In Congress: Claims Almost No Civilians Killed in Gaza; 3 Years After AIPAC Started Direct Donations To US Politicians, And After Israel's Darkest Year...
- Rabbi Explains The Biblical Prophecy That Has Trump Assisting "The Jewish Kingdom Over All Of Mankind In Jerusalem," And "Surrendering" The United States To It; First His Right Ear Had To Be Grazed
- Trump Recording Emerges In Which He Reveals Netanyahu Never Wanted To Make A Deal. "I Thought The Palestinians Were Impossible And That The Israelis Would Do Anything To Make Peace And A Deal...
- Was WWI a Royal Affair? – Questions For Corbett
- Offsite Post: ‘The Bill Cassidy Comedy Tour’
- Poisoning Your Data – #SolutionsWatch
- A Brief History of Political Assassinations
- On the Love for God
- Homily on the Fourth Sunday of Matthew
- Feast of the Kazan Icon of the Mother Of God
- The Faith of the Centurion
- Saint Prokopios the Great Martyr
- Fourth Sunday after Pentecost
- The Final Days of the Iconic Fashion Designer Billy Bo
- Offsite Post: ‘The Good Ol’ Boy Network Extends beyond Louisiana’
- Interview 1893 – ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED??? (NWNW 562)
- Our Summit For Our Future – #SolutionsWatch
- Through Hallucinations and Delirium: What Words Will I Be Repeating on My Deathbed?
- Offsite Post: ‘St Brigid vs Taylor Swift: Examining What Is Truly Beautiful for Our Daughters’
- Offsite Post: ‘Elements’
- Offsite Post: ‘The First Amendment Has Got to Go!’
- Results of Our 2024 Easter Basket Charity Event
- Achieving Serenity in Social Bonds: Insights from Bishop Athanasios
- “We Didn’t Hold a Grudge Against God despite the Shock”: A Story of a Terrible Diagnosis, Acceptance, and a Miracle
- The Mountain that Bears the Lord’s Footprint
- Children’s Health Defense Responds to SCOTUS Decision in Murthy v. Missouri
- CHD Scientists Discover Vaccine-Induced Diseases in Infants Increase Exponentially with Every Added Vaccine
- New Study by CHD’s Brian Hooker and Jacob Puliyel, M.D. Raises Safety Concerns Over Infant Rotavirus Vaccine in India
- New Book from CHD/Skyhorse Publishing Chronicles Illegal Military Anthrax Jab Mandate
- Unyielding
- CHD Asks Supreme Court to Hear Case Alleging FDA Misused Emergency Power by Authorizing COVID Shots for Children
- Autobiography of Alexandros Papadiamantis
- A hindu convert to Orthodoxy
- Un hindus convertit la Ortodoxie
- Alexandros Papadiamantis Resource Page
- How Great Spiritual Figures of Greece Helped Form the Renowned Conductor Dimitri Mitropoulos
- Artificial Intelligence as Artificial Brilliance (Metr. Hierotheos of Nafpaktos)
- How to fight any passion
- Pr. Serghei Baranov – Cum să te lupți împotriva oricărei patimi
- The Catacomb Church (1991)
- Movie: "Men of Anjolos" (1997) - An Islamic Movie on the Life of the Seven Youths of Ephesus
- The story of a repentant Sergian Priest!
- A brutal crush and a dark Ecclesiastical secret!
- Tortured for Orthodoxy: concerning Mother Joanna (†1998)
- 41 Testimonies: on Sergianism and the "ecclesial" status of the Soviet Church
- Hymn of love
- Imnul iubirii
- The Eternal Day
- Follow Me
- I will give you rest
- Single Mind, Simple Life – Gospel for the Third Sunday of Matthew
- Save your soul with fear of God
- Enduring skillfully
- Orthodoxy is unique
Cele mai citite
- Să învățăm să iubim
- Clark Carlton: Modernity considers sub-natural existence the sumit of human progress
- Dostoevsky for Parents and Children: (IV) Merchant Skotoboinikov's Story
- O mica problema de retorica
- 101 carti de necitit intr-o viata
- O stire: moartea presei.
- Totalitarism homosexual
- Alternativa Nicusor Dan. Nula
- Cu ochii larg închiși
- Evolutionism pe intelesul tuturor
Dupa dealuri | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
Critica de film |
Scris de Ninel Ganea |
Miercuri, 30 Ianuarie 2013 22:34 |
In primul rand, nu poate exista o formula “value free” de tratare artistica a unei teme. Asta nu inseamna imediat ca toata arta e ideologie, ci ca este important sa distingem, in masura in care putem, presupozitiile autorului, filozofia propusa, publicul sedus, contextul narativ. Toate acestea sunt independente de valoarea artistica, cel putin pe termen scurt. La Mungiu subtextele nu reies cu una, cu doua, la iveala, dar daca ne uitam mai atent la pelicula, incep sa ne sara in ochi. Filmul nu se adreseaza “fanaticilor”, ci “caldiceilor", oameni suspendati intre optiuni de viata mai angajante, cei care practica uzul ratiunii critice peste tot, mai putin in cazul ratiunii insesi. De la bun inceput se poate observa o anumita stereotipie a imaginii Bisericii; in tabla aflata pe poarta manastirii troneaza schiop maxima “crede si nu cerceta”, o vorba apartinand lui Celsus, un pagan anticrestin din sec. II, dar bun de inchiriat la ocazie si azi pentru o poanta anti-bisericeasca. Sigur ca ne putem baza pe “se non e vero e ben trovato”, insa exista atat de multe instante in film sub care putem folosi scuza aceasta (relatia dintre cele doua tinere, “mami” si “tati”, etc), incat riscam sa intram intr-o dimensiune complet fabulatorie. Asadar, regizorul nu isi propune sa faca o caricatura iluminista a calugariei. E suficient de matur artistic si intelectual incat sa evite capcana unui pamflet cinematografic. Dar asta nu inseamna ca suntem scutiti de innuendouri anticlericale consistente, care merg de la cliseele verbale ale maicilor, pana la chestionari “decisive” rostite de nebuna intru lesbianism, Alina, “de ce nu au voie femeile in altar?”. Ai senzatia suparatoare, pe alocuri, ca autorul isi propune sa ne arate mai degraba o copie a imaginii pe care o are despre calugarie un intelectual crescut la scoala gandirii noi si mai putin “imaginea reala a subdezvoltarii noastre, de la saracia manastirii si pana la ursul urias de plus cu care Alina umbla prin casa parintilor sai de imprumut, un urs mare cat toate jucariile pe care nu le-a avut cand era mica.. “ Pentru a descoperi spectatorul tinta, Voichita reprezinta personajul cheie. Fiinta neintegrata decisiv in rutina manastarii, cu o sensibilitate aparte si un trecut trist, ea isi pastreaza distanta critica, rationala fata de personajul colectiv al maicutelor, subsumat lui “mami”. Si implicit asupra staretului la care se raporteaza, de cele mai multe ori, doar emotional. Cateva excese metaforice ale regizorului cred ca sprijina aceasta interpretare. De pilda, in discutia purtata in fata lumanarilor cu parintele, in cadrul de fundal se poate vedea limpede in dreptul clericului inscriptia “morti”, in timp ce plecarea tinerei ne dezvaluie destinatia personajului, “vii” (pentru lume?). In acelasi sens, finalul debordeaza de simboluri, de la vestimentatia Voichitei eliberata de rasa monahala si imbracata cu puloverul Alinei, pana la figura ei remarcabil de cooperanta in grupul de maici anchetate. Tot in acelasi registru poate fi citita si fuga, la un moment dat, din ingradirea manastirii. Metocul nu e populat cu inchizitori ortodocsi fanatizati, insa nici nu trece testul acceptabilitatii contemporane. E o institutie poate mai blanda decat celelalte (politia, spitalul) dar le fel de inadecvata problemelor omului modern. In fata absurdului vietii are raspunsuri nepotrivite, fara upgrade, ba chiar destul de problematice. Manastirea poate fi un excelent azil pentru femei cu probleme personale sau adapost pentru nevoiase, insa rateazea clar misiunea sa spirituala. |